Case Law Research

CESTAT Chennai : M/s. Roots Multiclean Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of Central Excise, Coimbatore : 10th March, 2017


E/560 & 561/2008
(Arising out of Order-in-Appeal No.92 & 93/2008-CE dated 29.9.2008 passed by the Commissioner of Customs, Central Excise and Service Tax (Appeals), Coimbatore)

M/s. Roots Multiclean Ltd.


Commissioner of Central Excise, Coimbatore

Shri K. Subash Chandran, Advocate for the Appellant
Shri R. Subramaniyam, AC (AR) for the Respondent

Honble Shri D.N. Panda, Judicial Member
Honble Shri Madhu Mohan Damodhar, Technical Member

Date of Hearing / Decision: 10.03.2017

FINAL ORDER Nos. 40430-40431 / 2017

Per D.N. Panda

Appellant says that the goods in question were Automatic Scrubber Driver and its Accessoriesand that is stored for consumption on board, a vessel of the Indian Navy as has been certified by the Naval authority in terms of the copy of the certificate No. LP/10083/800(a)7/05-06 dated 16th May 2006 and No. LP/00051/800(a)7/06-07 dated 27th October 2006 (available at pages 33 and 36 of the appeal folder). This certificate shows that the goods in question were exclusively purchased for use on board in Naval Ship. Therefore, the appellant is entitled to exemption under Notification No. 64/95-CE dated 16.3.1995.

2. Revenue says that those goods were not used in the vessel on board of Indian Navy.

3. Heard both sides and perused the records.

4. To agree with Revenue, there is no material on record conducting any enquiry. Therefore, there can neither be a presumption in favour of Revenue without Tribunal having power to presume certain things to hold in its favour. Accordingly, appellant cannot be denied the benefit of the exemption Notification which is permissible in terms of the certificate issued by the naval authority.

5. In the result, both the appeals are allowed.

(Dictated and pronounced in open court)

(Madhu Mohan Damodhar)                           (D.N. Panda)
Technical Member                                         Judicial Member


Additional Info

  • Date Range: Friday, 10 March 2017
  • Court/Authority: CESTAT
  • Tax Type: Central Excise
  • Petitioner/Appellant: M/s. Roots Multiclean Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of Central Excise, Coimbatore
  • Respondent: M/s. Roots Multiclean Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of Central Excise, Coimbatore
  • Appl no. or Appl year: E/560 & 561/2008
  • Supreme Court Location: Delhi
  • CESTAT Location: Chennai
  • AAR Location: Delhi
  • Authority: Supreme Court

A New Feature :

Advanced Case Law Search


7th April, 2016

The “Advanced Case Law Search” feature in TaxQuotient  enables search on separate parameters such as Court, Tax Type, Date (from & to Range), appellant, respondent and even keywords. This helps you in locating case law you are searching for swiftly.

TIP: #1 : If you want to view the latest cases, just enter the start and end dates keeping all other boxes blank. You will get a list of all available indirect tax cases during that period.

TIP # 2 : Please keep the date range (start to end date) for upto 6 months.

TIP # 3 : Don't forget to reset the search to clear the earlier results before a new search.

Click to enter Advanced Case Law Search

 GST Bill passed by Parliament




The 122nd Constitution Amendment Bill introduced in Parliament in December 2014 has been passed by the Rajya Sabha and now also by the Lok Sabha with the amendments.  Now the Bill must get ratified by at least half the number of 31 State Legislatures which means 16 States and then finally get the approval from the President.

Thereafter the GST Council has to be set up which will determine the GST design at the granular level. This will include the structure of GST including scope of CGST, SGST and IGST, the taxes subsumed, the items/commodities covered and other critical aspects such as the threshold limits for taxability, exemptions, and several other parameters critical for an ideal  GST.

Further, for the GST to operate smoothly, the taxes paid on goods and services at every stage in the value chain needs to be tracked. This requires an IT infrastructure which will track the transactions and taxes paid and form the back-bone of GST. Reportedly considerable work has been already done on it, nevertheless it will need changes to correctly reflect the GST Law proposed by the GST Council and accepted by the Central & State Legislatures.

Last but not the least,  the tax authorities and other stakeholders who will implement the GST need to be trained for a smooth introduction.

Seven questions to know if you 

are paying taxes 


If you are the CFO or the Tax Head you ought to read this. Click Here

CESTAT Updates

June- July 2016


Brief update on CESTAT judgements passed during June 2016 to July 2016. Please note this update is not a summary of the cases but only leads on important issues decided. The links to the judgments are also provided for the full text.

Click here for update

Our Main Services 

in Indirect Taxes


  • Business structuring and tax planning
  • Review of end-to-end business processes for indirect taxes
  • Strategy to prevent litigation, representation and litigation support
  • Tax compliance and tax control framework
  • Support on specific issues
Go to top