CBIC confirms tax evasion and acknowledges concerns on GST AAR orders

13th December

The Central Board of Indirect Taxes & Customs (CBIC) confirms that despite anti-evasion measures adopted when implementing GST, the tax evasion in GST during Apr-Nov 2018 amounted to Rs 12K Crores.

The CBIC also acknowledged concerns of the industry and trade that orders from GST AAR State Benches are sometimes conflicting. The solution to this was a National AAR which would reflect reflect a uniform approach for the whole of India. However this idea for a national AAR bench appears to have hit a road block as it requires around 40 members with every state being represented.

 

The next indirect tax reform is aimed at customs procedures to boost trade and improve ease of doing business

4th December

The Chairman of CBIC, Mr S Ramesh elaborated that current customs procedures will be replaced by processes in line with best practices of the World Customs Organisation (WCO). This will entail eliminating face-to-face contact with tax officials, automated clearance of goods, linking ports to enable flexibility to assess goods landed in other ports, e-traceability of shipments etc. These will speed up clearances and substantially reduce corruption.

Mr Ramesh said “We want to go in for something which will be radically different from what we have been doing. We are going to venture into a new territory called faceless assessment... We could start a pilot in a month’s time,”

These steps are likely to enable India to boost its ranking getting into the top 50 rank (currently 80) of the World Bank’s Ease of Doing Business.

Supreme Court dislodges Rajasthan HC judgement and denies IT exemption to Urban Improvement Trust

22nd October

 

SC has dislodged a Rajasthan HC judgement saying the Urban Improvement Trust set up under the State law is neither a  "municipality" nor a "municipal board". The SC inter alia holds:

"The word “Municipal Committee” occurring in Clause (iii) Explanation, thus, has a definite purpose and object.

Purpose and object was to cover those bodies, which are discharging municipal functions but are not covered by the definition of municipalities as was required to be constituted by Article 243Q of the Constitution of India. Urban Improvement Trust constituted under the Rajasthan Urban Improvement Act, 1959, thus, cannot be held to be covered by the definition of Municipal Committee as contained in Clause (iii) of Explanation to Section 10(20) of the I.T. Act......"

Read the full text of the judgement.

Ministry of Statictics seeks GST data to improve Accounts

19th October

It has been reported that the Ministry of Statistics & Programme Implementation (MSPI) has sought quarterly GST data (output, input and revenue) on tax paying units from the Ministry of Finance.

This data is expected to improve the quality, timeliness and credibility  of both National Accounts Statistics and state-level accounts. Also this step is expected to reduce data collection cost. Apparently, the Finance Ministry will share this data one the GST system stabilises.

 

Fraudulent GST invoices to the tune of Rs 245 Crores and evasion of Rs 42 Crore detected by Bengaluru State GST Authorities

18th October

A businessman name Mangilal was arrested and later remanded to judicial custody on Tuesday 16th October.

The State GST authorities after preliminary investigations alleged that Mangilal issued fake invoices to the tune of Rs 245 Crore. They also alleged that he evaded GST of Rs. 42 crore.

His modus operandi included obtaining a GST registration in  the name of a deceased person and  issuing invoices in that name or of fictitious persons.

 

Goods in the factory can't be offending goods. When physical control operates, goods outside the factory must be presumed duty paid

17th October, 2018

Goods "lying within the factory premises were not contravening goods and had not violated any provision of Central Excise Act and, therefore, their confiscation is set aside."

"...goods which were confiscated such as at the transporter premises of Baba Roadlines.... the redemption fine cannot be directed to be paid by the appellants because said goods were proceed to have been manufactured by the appellant.

"...2,88,000 sticks of Captan brand cigarettes stated to have been found in excess at the residential premises of Shri Roop Singh .....cannot be contravening goods because the manufacturers factory was under physical control and it was not possible to remove manufactured goods without payment of duty...."  Musk Tobacco & Ors Vs CCE, Lucknow

 

Recent Court / Tribunal Judgements

 National Anti-profiteering Authority

Decisions for the National Anti-Profiteering Authority :

  1. 1. Shri Ankur Jain & DG Anti-Profiteering, CBIC Vs M/s Kunj Lub Marketing Pvt. Ltd. : Case No. : 10/2018 : 8th October, 2018
  2. 2. Sh. Jijrushu N. Bhattacharya & DG Anti-Profiteering, CBIC  Vs M/s NP Foods (Franchisee M/s Subway India) : Case No. 9/2018 : 27th September, 2018
  3. 3. Miss Neeru Varshney & DG Anti-Profiteering, CBIC Vs M/s Lifestyle International Pvt. Ltd. : Case No. 8/2018 : 25th September, 2018
  4. 4. Shri Sukhbir Rohilla along & 108 other Applicants & DG Anti-Profiteering, CBIC Vs M/s Pyramid Infratech Pvt. Ltd. : Case No. 7/2018 : 18th September, 2018  
  5. 5. Shri Pawan Sharma & DGAP, CBIC Vs M/s Sharma Trading Company, Jaipur: Case No. 6/2018 : 7th September, 2018
  6. 6. Dinesh Mohan Bhardwaj Vs M/s Vrandavaneshwree, Automotive Private Limited : Case No. 1/2018 : 27th March 2018

 CESTAT Decisions

 

18th October, 2018 : CESTAT Mum : UPS Jetair Express Private Limited   Vs Commissioner of CGST, Mumbai East 

Revenue denied CENVAT credit only on the ground invoices didn't mention the registration number of the service provider. No other allegations were made regarding receipt of input services, eligibility etc.

Held : This is merely a procedural lapse. It is settled that CENVAT credit can't be denied on mere technicalities or procedural lapses.

CENVAT credit allowed, extended period of limitation not applicable.

Ed's comment : Isnt it surprising that a Senior Officer like Prin. ADG, DGPM, WRU, still needs to catch up with decades old case law regarding Modvat and Cenvat? It's repeatedly held procedural lapses aren't reason enough to deny credit. How will the dept reduce litigation? Should Tribunal for fairness?

18th October, 2018 : CESTAT Ahd : M/s Auto Care Lubricant Vs C.C.E. & S.T.-Vapi
The Tribunal relying on an earlier decision in Castrol India Ltd, held :
“The authorities under the Standards of Weights and Measures Act are the best judge to decide as to whether a product is required to be affixed with a MRP under the said Act or not. If said authority has clarified that 210 ltr. barrel are not required to be affixed with MRP, it was obligatory on the part of the Excise authority to accept such decision of Controller of Legal Metrology authority….., it was not open to the Excise authority to doubt the decision of the authority under Standards of Weights and Measures Act and to proceed independently ….”

18th October 2018 : CESTAT Ahd : M/s Javiya Finance Services, Javiya Marketing Vs C.C.E.& S.T.- Surat-I
The appellant were providing service of identifying customers for car loans and receiving commission from ICICI Bank. This was to be taxed under Business Auxiliary Services (BAS).  

The appellants admitted taxability but argued they were under bonafide belief the services are not taxable and so extended period of limitation should not be invoked.
Held : "The definition of Business  Auxiliary  Services  is  very  clear  and  there  is  no  scope  of interpretation. The definition specifically includes the service of promotion or marketing of any service of the client within its ambit." Appeals dismissed.

 

 12th Oct : CESTAT Mum : Tahnee Heights CHS Ltd. Vs Commissioner of CGST, Mumbai South : Held : "The appellant also do not provide any service to its members, who pay the amount towards their share of contribution, for occupation of the units ....the explanation furnished under clause 3(a) in Section 65B of the Act will not designate the appellant as an entity, separate from its members....the case of the appellant is not confirming to the requirement of 'service', as per the definition contained in Section 65B(44) of the Act."

10th Oct : CESTAT Ahd :  L & T Ltd. etc Vs C.C.E. Ahd Appellants argued the law and IS specifications had changed for their product "concrete mix" made at site. It was eligible for the exemption making the earlier Supreme Court judgement in their own case irrelevant.

Tribunal ruled that there is no change in the  C.Ex Tariff Heading description as far as ready mix concrete is concerned. There is no mention of any IS Specification anywhere in the SC judgement. So changes in IS Specifications cannot be used to distinguish the decision of Hon’ble Apex Court. Demand beyond the period of limitation set aside. Personal penalty quashed as this is a case of interretation.

11th Oct : CESTAT Chennai : M/s. Pepsico India HPL Vs Commr of GST & CE, Chennai Outer : The appellants had paid excess central excise duty for which they utilised the CENVAT credit. On realizing this they suo moto took re-credit of the excess amount debited from the Cenvat account.

Held:  Following the said decisions of the High Courts, The impugned order and demand was set aside.

3rd October, 2018 : Mayur Printers & Ors Vs C.C.E.& S.T. Surat-I :

Two points were raised in the Rectification of Mistake Application. First, credit denied on defective gate passes and second, there was no findings in respect of cenvat credit lying in their account which should have been adjusted against the demand. Tribunal held - credit admissible if established through evidence. Matter remanded.

3rd October, 2018: CESTAT Ahd C.C., Kandla Vs Reliance Port & Terminals Ltd.: Revenue argued thatEPCG benefit was not available for “consumables” which was deleted from Not 97/2004 Cus on 21.5.2007. “Consumables” are not “capital goods”.  Respondents submitted the imported items were “used for installation of Crude. Product pipelines, therefore, all the goods used during the initial installation of pipeline shall be categorized as capital goods only.” The Tribunal dismissed the appeal on limitation without entering the merits of the case as the Revenue had abandoned the argument of limitation.

 

 

High Court Judgements

 

2nd July, 2018  : Allahabad High Court : Hamdard (Wakf) Labs Vs Commr Of Commercial Taxes : The High Court upholds the Tribunal order and holds that "Sharbat "Rooh Afza" is not unclassifiable under Schedule-V of the Act and liable to tax @ 12.5%. It is neither fruit juice nor fruit drink nor processed fruit.

2nd July, 2018 :  Delhi High Court : JOYCE KAROUNG Vs NARCOTICS CONTROL BUREAU : Relying on the SC judgment in Babua v. State of Orissa, (2001) 2 SCC 566 the High Court concluded the petitioner is not prima facie not guilty. Also, liberty of a citizen must be balanced with the interest of the society especially where narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances are involved. It is alleged that this is not the first offence.

Click for earlier Judgements in 2018

Specialists in Indian indirect taxation

Article

Title Author
Archived links to external articles - 2018 - 1A Written by Editor
Another "disaster cess"​ in the offing to manage natural calamities? Written by Editor
12th October, 2018 : Supreme Court of India : ALD AUTOMOTIVE PVT. LTD. Vs CTO etc Written by Editor
The benefit of lower tax notified has to be passed on for every product/pack (SKU). Written by Editor
Archived links to external articles - 2018 Page 2 Written by Editor
GST Council reduces rates on several items, simplifies returns Written by Editor
GST - Good & Simple Tax? Written by Editor
Malaysia to scrap GST from 1st June - What it means for India? Written by Editor
Archived links to external articles - 2018 Page 5 Written by Editor
What is the logic for a new sugar cess to run parallel with GST? Written by Editor
CBI arrests customs officers & CHA for alleged bribery Written by Editor
Tax News - April 2018 Written by Editor
"Duty Free Shops" are no more "duty free" in Indian International Airports Written by Editor
GST Council keeps RCM on hold Written by Editor
E-Way Bill in 6 States for intra-State movement of goods from 20th April 2018. Maharashtra will introduce from 1st May Written by Editor
March - April 2018 High Lights Written by Editor
Customs Circulars Issued in 2016 Written by Editor
Circulars issued Under Legacy Taxes Written by Editor
Central, Integrated & UT Tax Notifications Written by Editor
Central, Integrated & UT Tax Circulars Written by Editor
Archived links to external articles - 2018 Written by Editor
Archived links to external articles - 2018 Page 3 Written by Editor
Archived links to external articles - 2018 Page 4 Written by Editor
Minutes of GST Council Meetings Written by Editor
Central Excise Circulars issued in 2018 Written by Editor
Customs Circulars issued in 2018 Written by Editor
Service tax Circulars issued in 2017 Written by Editor
CGST Circulars issued in 2017 Written by Editor
IGST Circulars issued in 2017 Written by Editor
Compensation Cess Circulars issued in 2017 Written by Editor
Customs Circulars issued in 2017 Written by Editor
Central Excise Circulars issued in 2017 Written by Editor
GST Central Tax Notifications issued in 2017 Written by Editor
GST Integrated Tax Notifications in 2017 Written by Editor
GST Integrated Tax Rate Notifications in 2017 Written by Editor
Union Territory GST Notifications issued in 2017 Written by Editor
Union Territory GST Notifications issued in 2018 Written by Editor
GST : Union Territory Rate Notifications issued in 2018 Written by Editor
Union Territory GST Rate Notifications issued in 2017 Written by Editor
Compensation Cess Rate Notifications issued in 2017 Written by Editor
Compensation Cess Rate Notifications issued in 2018 Written by Editor
Compensation Cess Notifications issued in 2017 Written by Editor
Compensation Cess Notifications issued in 2018 Written by Editor
Customs Notifications issued in 2018 Written by Editor
Government Reports on GST Written by Editor
GST Presentations & Updates Written by Editor
GST - Press releases Written by Editor
GST FAQs Written by Editor
Budget 2018-19 Highlights in bullets Written by Editor
Economic Survey of India - 2017-18 Written by Editor
GST Central Tax Notifications issued in 2018 Written by Editor
GST Central Tax Rate Notifications issued in 2018 Written by Editor
GST - Integrated Tax Notifications issued in 2018 Written by Editor
GST - Integrated Tax Rate Notifications issued in 2018 Written by Editor
GST Central Tax Rate Notifications issued in 2017 Written by Editor
GST Central Tax Circulars issued in 2018 Written by Editor
GST Orders Written by Editor
GST Integrated Tax Circulars issued in 2018 Written by Editor
GST - UT Tax Circulars issued in 2018 Written by Editor
GST - Compensation Cess Circulars issued in 2018 Written by Editor
Classification Of Goods Under GST Written by Editor
Union Budget 2017-18 Economic Survey, Budget Speech and Budget Documents
GST - Circulars etc issued for migration to GST : Registration/Enrollment under GST for existing tax payers. Written by Editor
Union Budget 2017-18 : Customs, Central Excise & Service Tax Notifications
Goods & Services Tax (GST) - Reports, documents etc. (in reverse chronological order) Written by Editor
Union Budget 2016-17 - Documents Written by Editor
The High Court rejects the Revenue's reference in a 41 year old case. The question raised is - Whether it's "gold in primary form" or "bangles"? Written by Editor
Links to State Tax Legislations & Notifications Written by Editor
Central Government constitutes committee to simplify the Income Tax Act, 1961 Written by Editor
Ministry of Finance invites on 3 GST reports by Joint Committee Written by Editor
Tax Risk Management - Controls Written by Editor
Central Government publishes rules for black money valuation Written by Editor
Supreme Court rules deemed export benefit received from Govt and not buyer is also additional consideration when it impacts the selling price. Written by Editor
Supreme Court says prior to 1st June, 2007 the Finance Act has no provision to levy service tax on indivisible composite works contracts Written by Editor
Whether the Tribunal can dismiss an appeal for non appearance? Written by Editor
GST bill listed for passing in Rajya Sabha today Written by Editor
List of Articles Written by Editor
Central Govt. notifies rules to administer Indo-US FATCA Written by Editor
Wholesale Price Index at historic low, a positive impact on the markets Written by Editor
Union Budget 2018-19 Written by Editor
Provisions of time bar under section 11B not applicable to service tax paid under a mistaken understanding of facts . Written by Editor
Hyderabad High Court steps in twice in a stay application matter to render justice Written by Editor
Will the Government grab the opportunity and implement a perfect GST? Written by Editor
Government porposes tax cuts for use of credit/debit cards Written by Editor
Amway Distributors get away lightly in service tax case before the CESTAT Delhi Bench Written by Editor
Measuring Tax Performance Written by Editor
The Supreme Court of India on the exceptions to "principles of natural justice" Written by Editor
Supreme Court upholds validity of retroactive amendment of 1993 to s 143(1A) but will apply only to evasion cases. Written by Editor
Supreme Court rules : In Gujarat sales tax, if the works order is for "fabrication & installation" composition tax @ 5% under entry 5 will apply not 15% under entry 2. Written by Editor
What is the correct classification of self-adhesive security holograms? Whether as "self-adhesive tapes" or as "products of the printing industry"? Written by Editor
Will SAD exemption apply to stock transfers from SEZ to DTA unit of same manufacturer? Written by Editor
In Its First Budget, Maharashtra Govt abolishes LBT Written by Editor
TP relief for MNCs from Delhi High Court - 16th March 2015 judgement. Written by Editor
Budget 2015-16: Notifications in Central Excise, Customs & Service Tax Written by Editor
Some Expectations regarding Indirect Tax in Budget 2015-16 Written by Editor
Can cenvat credit be availed on services received outside India where service tax is paid on reverse charge basis? Written by Editor
Tax authorities reject refund claim saying there is no proof while ignoring shipping bills and invoices Written by Editor
Can the appellate authority ignore existence of prima facie case when considering the stay applications? Allahabad High Court says, no. Written by Editor
Will an undertaking provided at the time of take-over of factory, apply to fresh liabilities which arise later? Written by Editor
Is interest payable for delay in Cenvat debit even if there was adequate Cenvat Credit balance? Written by Editor
Affixing any price as MRP will not entitle assessment under section 4A. Written by Editor
Latest CESTAT Decisions Written by Editor
Uber India Agrees To Pay Service Tax Written by Editor
GST - When can we expect it? Written by Editor
Supreme Court Cases List (being updated) Written by Editor
Supreme Court - Case Law List Written by Editor
AP High Court declines answering questions raised in reference application. Written by Editor
Improperly Constituted “Committee of Chief Commissioners of Central Excise” Costs Revenue its Appeal Written by Editor
Error noticed by 2nd Audit & credit reversed. Extended period inapplicable. No interest. Written by Editor
Supreme Court rules - criminals should not be part of Government Written by Editor
Relief for Jayalalithaa - gets bail from Supreme Court Written by Editor
Justice H L Dattu was sworn in as the 42nd Chief Justice of India Written by Editor
Supreme Court overrules Delhi HC in the illegal mining criminal case Written by Editor
AIE to trace illicit money flows How it can help India? Written by Editor
CESTAT Mumbai Decisions Written by Editor
The Supreme Court of India - Novartis Judgement on Patents after TRIPS agreement. Written by Editor
Tribunal Reverses Commr Appeals Order Allowing Retraction of Statement In a Case of Clandestine behaviour 4 Years later at Appellate Stage Written by Editor
TN CM Jayalalithaa Convicted and Sentenced to 4 year Jail Term by Bangalore Court Written by Editor
Cenvat Credit available even on documents which do not cover or accompany consignments Written by Editor
Supreme Court cancels 214 Coal Block Allotments Written by Editor
Tax Risk Management - Part 3 Written by Editor
Splendid work by C.Ex, Noida - Tribunal Uses Strong Expressions against the Partner & CHA Written by Editor
Supreme Court Constitutional Bench dismisses Income Tax appeals Written by Editor
Revenue Secretary Says GST possible from April 2016 Written by Editor
Department likely to lose as documents are untraceable. Appellant not provided with documents for over 7 years! Written by Editor
Credit admissible even if received before registration Written by Editor
Judgements of Courts in Other Countries - International Written by Editor
India's FATCA Written by Editor
SEBI Order holds PACL is a Collective Incentive Scheme (CIS) Written by Editor
When will the Revenue Stop disputing Written by Editor
Why We Still Don't Have a GST? Written by Editor
Supreme Court rejects Subramanian Swamy’s Contempt Petition Mr Arun Shourie Written by Editor
US closes in on Tax Dodgers - Record number want to quit US Written by Editor
Union Budget 2014-15 - Speech and Documents Written by Editor
New SEBI Law Gets Approval from Lok Sabha Written by Editor
Just Before the Budget.... Written by Editor
Tax Priorities For The New Government Written by Editor
Pondering Just Before the Budget Written by Editor
New Interest Rates for Service Tax Written by Editor
A Regressive Step - Six Months Time Limit for Cenvat Credit Written by Editor
What's in Budget 2014-15? Written by Editor
LTU A Less Attractive Option Now Written by Editor
An undesirable change - Mandatory Pre-deposit To Entertain Appeals Written by Editor
Latest CESTAT Decisions Chennai Written by Editor
Latest CESTAT Decisions Kolkata Written by Editor
Latest CESTAT Decisions Delhi Written by Editor
Latest CESTAT Decisions Bangalore Written by Editor
Latest CESTAT Decisions - Ahmedabad Written by Editor
Are You GST Ready? Know Your GST - Part 1 Written by Editor
Cascading taxes in CENVAT - When will it ever end? Written by Editor
Government Reports, Papers Relevant for Taxation Written by Editor
There is a crying need for change in Indian taxation Written by Editor
Will the new Government introduce tax reforms quickly? What do businesses want?

Tax Risk Management Part 1

An Introduction

 

Risk comes from not knowing what you’re doing. 
- Warren Buffet

Read the Article

 

Tax Risk Management Part 2

Tax Risks as Black Swan Events!

If you were asked "What 'tax risks' you perceive in your business?" What would be your answer?

Read the Article

 

 

Indirect Tax Risk Management

Indirect Risk Tax Management
 

 

 

 

Economic Survey of India 2017-18